Vodacom Now!
vodacom.co.za
16th May 19

Opinion

Should AI be used to catch shoplifters?

16th May 19

Vodacom
By Vodacom 1590 Followers

New artificial intelligence software is being used in Japan to monitor the body language of shoppers and look for signs that they are planning to shoplift.

The software, which is made by a Tokyo startup called Vaak, differs from similar products that work by matching faces to criminal records. Instead, VaakEye uses behaviour to predict criminal activity. Company founder Ryo Tanaka said his team fed the algorithm 100,000 hours worth of surveillance data to train it to monitor everything from the facial expressions of shoppers to their movements and clothing. Since VaakEye launched last month, it has been rolled out in 50 stores across Japan.

Vaak claims that shoplifting losses dropped by 77% during a test period in local convenience stores. That could help reduce global retail costs from shoplifting, which hit $34 billion in 2017 according to the Global Shrink Index.

Moral questions

Using AI to catch thieves raises all kinds of ethical questions.

'While the incentive is to prevent theft, is it legal or even moral to prevent someone from entering a store based on this software?' said Euromonitor retail analyst Michelle Grant. This should not be up to the software developer, says Tanaka. 'What we provide is the information of the suspicious, detected image. We don't decide who is criminal, the shop decides who's criminal,' he said. 

Yet that is precisely what concerns the human rights charity Liberty, which is campaigning to ban facial recognition technology in the United Kingdom. 'A retail environment — a private body — is starting to perform something akin to a police function,' said Hannah Couchman, Liberty's advocacy and policy officer.

Liberty is also worried about the potential of AI to fuel discrimination. A 2018 study by MIT and Stanford University found that various commercial facial-analysis programs demonstrated skin-type and gender biases. Tanaka explains that since the Vaak software is based on behaviour rather than race or gender, this should not be a problem. But Couchman remains sceptical. 'With technologies that rely on algorithms — particularly in regards to human behaviour — the potential for discrimination is always there,' she said. 'Humans have to teach the algorithm what to treat suspiciously.'

Customer Consent

Then there is the issue of transparency. 'Are people aware of what's happening?" asked Couchman. "Do they consent? Is it meaningful consent? What happens to the data? How is it protected? Might it be shared?'

Grant said consumers are willing to sacrifice some privacy for convenience — such as using face recognition for payment authentication — but only when they're aware the technology is being used. Tanaka does not dispute this. 'There should be notice before they [customers] enter the store so that they can opt out,' he said.

'Governments should operate rules that make stores disclose information — where and what they analyze, how they use it, how long they use it,' he said.

Christopher Eastham, a specialist in AI at the law firm Fieldfisher, said the framework for regulating the technology is not yet in place. 'There is a need for clarity from lawmakers and guidance from regulators, who will ultimately need to decide in what circumstances the use of this technology will be appropriate or desirable as a matter of public policy,' he said.

 

Suggested Posts

South Africa’s business sector holds the key to SME growth
stories

South Africa’s business sector holds the key to SME growth

Fatima Hassim | 22nd Aug 19

View more
The current state of our economy requires us to hone in on small business growth. We need to align our goals with those of government, which is looking to SMEs in its efforts to achieve the National Development Plan objective of creating 11 million new jobs by 2030.
Fatima Hassim
Fatima Hassim0 Followers
Amazon's cloud will connect Volkswagen's vast factory network
stories

Amazon's cloud will connect Volkswagen's vast factory network

Vodacom | 10th Jul 19

View more
Volkswagen and Amazon are teaming up to develop cloud computing that should make the German carmaker's vast factory network more productive.  
Vodacom
Vodacom 1590 Followers
The tech empowering disabled people in cities
stories

The tech empowering disabled people in cities

Vodacom | 9th Jul 19

View more
Cities are difficult to navigate at the best of times, but for people with disabilities, they can be like an obstacle course and a maze wrapped into one.
Vodacom
Vodacom 1590 Followers
Vodacom 2019. All rights reserved